Knowing, speaking, and naming according to Plato: a comparative reading of the Phaedrus and the Cratylus
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.32735/S0718-22012023000563047Keywords:
Plato, dialectic, Phaedrus, Cratylus, ontology, epistemologyAbstract
The current paper contains a comparative reading of the Phaedrus and the Cratylus. Some of their central topics are here contrasted in order to highlight the characteristic traits of Platonic thought present in both dialogues. The description of dialectic in the Phaedrus fits well with a Socratic definition in the Cratylus which clearly specifies that names are tools at the service of the dialectician. This evidence leads us to the conclusion that —besides being the main mechanism to control and judge rhetoric— dialectical technic appears in the dialogues as the only correcting procedure that makes it possible to verify any sort of proposition and bring speeches and depictions of reality closer to the truth.
Downloads
References
Ademollo, Francesco (2011). The Cratylus of Plato: A commentary. Cambridge University Press.
Alegre Gorri, Antonio (2018). Estudio introductorio. En Platón. Diálogos I (pp. xvii-cxxxii). Gredos.
—— (1986). La sofística y Sócrates: ascenso y caída de la polis. Barcelona: Montesinos.
Aronadio, Francesco (2002). Procedure e verità in Platone: Menone, Cratilo, Repubblica. Bibliopolis.
—— (1996). Cratilo. Bompiani.
Barney, Rachel (2003). Names and nature in Plato’s Cratylus. Routledge.
Bonazzi, Mauro (ed.) (2011). Platone: Fedro (traduzione e cura di Mauro Bonazzi). Giulio Einaudi editore.
—— (2010). I sofisti. Carocci.
Brancacci, Aldo (2011). L’elogio di Socrate nel Fedro, la chiusa dell’Eutidemo, e la polemica isocrateo-antistenico-platonica. En G. Casertano (a cura di). Il Fedro di Platone: struttura e problematiche (pp. 7-38). Loffredo.
Calvo, Tomás (1986). De los sofistas a Platón: política y pensamiento. Cincel.
Candel, Miguel (2004). Metafísica de cercanías. Montesinos.
Cassin, Barbara (1995). L’effet sophistique. Gallimard.
Di Cesare, Donatella (1980). La semantica nella filosofia greca. Bulzoni.
Griswold, Charles L. (1986). Self-knowledge in Plato’s Phaedrus. Yale University Press.
Fussi, Alessandra (2006). Retórica e potere: una lettura del Gorgia di Platone. Edizioni ETS.
Kahn, Charles (1998). Plato and the Socratic dialogue: The philosophical use of a literary form. Cambridge University Press.
Kerferd, George B. (1981). The sophistic movement. Cambridge University Press.
Lavilla de Lera, J. (2016). Tres discursos eróticos y dos concepciones anímicas en el Fedro de Platón. Agora: Papeles de Filosofía, 35, 1: 119-147. DOI: https://doi.org/10.15304/ag.35.1.2381
Mársico, Claudia T. (Ed.) (2006). Crátilo. Introducción, traducción y notas de C. T. Mársico. Losada.
Nightingale, Andrea W. (1995). Genres in dialogue: Plato and the construct of philosophy. Cambridge University Press.
Poratti, Armando (ed.) (2010). Platón: Fedro (introducción, trad., notas y comentario de A. Poratti). Istmo.
Pòrtulas, Jaume (2008). Introducció a la Ilíada: Homer, entre la història i la llegenda. Fundació Bernat Metge.
Rijlaarsdam, Jetske C. (1978). Platon über die Sprache: Ein Kommentar zum Kratylos; (mit einem) Anhang über die Quelle der Zeichentheorie Ferdinand de Saussures. Utrecht.
Tigerstedt, Eugène Napoleon (1977). Interpreting Plato. Almqvist & Wiksell international.
Too, Yun L. (1995). The rhetoric of identity in Isocrates. Cambridge University Press.
Tordesillas, Alonso (2013). “Discours rhétoriques et conduite des âmes: dialectique, psychagogie, politique dans le Phèdre de Platon”. En M. J. de Carvalho, A. Caeiro and H. Tello (eds.). In the Mirror of the Phaedrus (pp. 257-270). Academia Verlag.
Trabattoni, F. (2005). La verità nascosta. Roma: Carocci editore.
Trabattoni, Franco (2016). Essays on Plato's epistemology. Leuven University Press. DOI: https://doi.org/10.11116/EPE_AMP
Vegetti, Mario (2003). Quindici lezioni su Platone. Einaudi.
Zucchetti, Nicholas (2020). An unexplained overlap between Sophist 232b1-236d4 and Republic X. Revista Archai, 30. DOI: https://doi.org/10.14195/1984-249X_30_14
