Robbe-Grillet against Resnais, X against A and the reader against himself
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.32735/S0718-22012025000603237Keywords:
Literary fortifications, Evil, Feminist Hermeneutics, Robbe-GrilletAbstract
Resnais’s Last Year at Marienbad is considered one of the indisputable classics of modern cinema due to the series of technical, structural and narrative innovations it introduces, even so, a disturbing dimension of his was not fully addressed by specialized critics Only through feminist studies was it possible to begin to resignify what was hidden by the elegant and abstract formalism constructed by Robbe-Grillet and Resnais. In this sense, our reading starts from Higgins’ classic reading of Marienbad as an unconsciously phallocentric film, in which it is narrated the story of a rape and its subsequent cover-up; however, our hypothesis holds that Robbe-Grillet deliberately constructs an ambiguous device to maliciously subvert all knowledge. In this way, the consideration of Robbe-Grillet’s texts as hermeneutic “traps” thus opens a path of analysis that allows revealing novel elements to the film. Our work therefore proposes a comparative reading of Robbe-Grillet’s cine-roman and Resnais’s film to analyze the ways in which the former immanently plots to disavow the authorial figure of the latter and introduce confusion in the reader/spectator.
Downloads
References
Adorno, Theodor (2006) [1966]. “Transparencias cinematográficas”. Trad. Breixo Viejo. Archivo de la filmoteca, N°52.
Allemand, Roger (1997). Alain Robbe-Grillet. Seuil.
Anzieu, Didier (1993) [1981]. El cuerpo de la obra. Trad. Antonio Marquet. Siglo XXI,
Barilli, Renato (1972). “Aboutissement du roman phénoménologique ou nouvelle aventure romanesque”. En Jean Ricardou; Françoise Van Rossum-Guyon (ed), Nouveau Roman : hier, aujourd'hui. 1. Problèmes généraux. UGE.
Barthes, Roland (1973) [1964]. “Literatura objetiva”, “Literatura literal”, “¿Resumen de Robbe-Grillet?”. Trad. Carlos Pujol. En Ensayos críticos. Seix Barral.
Bataille, Georges (2010). La literatura y el mal. Trad. de Lourdes Ortiz. Nortesur.
Baudry, Jean (2016). “Cine: efectos ideológicos del aparato de base”. Trad. Emiliano Jelicié y Fernando La Valle. En La cámara opaca. Cuenco de Plata.
Blanchot, Maurice (1969). “La claridad novelesca”. Trad. de Pierre de Place. En El libro que vendrá. Monte Ávila.
Britton, Celia (1989). “The Nouveau Roman and Tel Quel Marxism”. En Paragraph, Vol.12, N°1.
Burch, Noel (1995). El tragaluz del infinito. Cátedra.
Comolli, Jean-Louis (2010). “¿Qué palabra?”. Trad. Horacio Pons. En Cine contra espectáculo. Seguido de Técnica e ideología. Manantial.
Dejean, Jean (2016). Literary Fortifications. Princeton Legacy Library .
Deleuze, Gilles (2012). La imagen-tiempo: estudios sobre cine II. Trad. de Irene Agoff. Paidós.
Derrida, Jacques (2017). “Esa extraña institución llamada literatura. Una entrevista de Derek Attridge con Jacques Derrida”. Trad. de Vicenç Tuset. En BOLETIN, N°18.
Foucault, Michel (1996). “Distancia, aspecto, origen”. Trad. Isidro Herrera Baquero. En De lenguaje y literatura. Paidós.
Fragola, Antonhy; Smith, Roch (1992). The Erotic Dream Machine. Interviews with Alain Robbe-Grillet on His Films. Southern Illinois University Press.
Genette, Gerard (2001). Umbrales. Trad. de Susana Lage. Siglo XXI.
Grossi, Bruno (2021). “La belleza enigmática del fuego. Robbe-Grillet más acá y más allá de Barthes”. Saga, Vol°2, N°14.
Higgins, Lynn (1991). “Screen/Memory: Rape and Its Alibis in Last Year at Marienbad”. En Rape and Representation- Columbia Press.
Hill, Leslie (1984). “Robbe-Grillet: formalism and its discontents”. En Paragraph, Vol. 3.
Jefferson Kline, Thomas (2010). Unraveling French Cinema. Wiley-Blackwell.
________ (2008). “Double projection”. En Artforum.
Kogonada (2013). “What Is Neorealism?”, videoensayo. En Sight & Sound. Disponible en: http://kogonada.com/portfolio/what-is-neorealism
Morrissette, Bruce (1972). “Robbe-Grillet n° 1, 2... X”. Jean Ricardou; Françoise Van Rossum-Guyon (ed.) Nouveau Roman : hier, aujourd’hui. 2, Pratiques. UGE.
Ricardou, Jean (1971). Pour une théorie du nouveau roman. Seuil.
Rivette, Jacques; Labarthe, André (1961). “Entretien avec Alain Resnais et Alain Robbe-Grillet”. En Cahiers du cinéma, XXI (123.
Robbe-Grillet, Alain (2010) [1963]. Por una nueva novela. Cactus.
________ (2001). Le voyageur. Christian Bourgois.
________ (1986) [1984]. El espejo que vuelve. Anagrama.
________ (1972). “Discussion”. En Jean Ricardou; Françoise Van Rossum-Guyon (ed.) Nouveau Roman : hier, aujourd’hui. 1. Problèmes généraux. UGE.
________ (1962) [1961]. El año pasado en Marienbad. Seix Barral,
Rosenbaum, Jonathan (2008). “The Greatest Film Ever Made?”. En Chicago Reader. Disponible en https://chicagoreader.com/film/the-greatest-film-ever-made/
Rybalka, Michel (1986). “Alain Robbe-Grillet: at play with criticism”. En Lois Oppenheim (ed.), Three Decades of the French New Novel. University of Illinois Press.
Sanchez Moreno, Iván (2021). “Perdidos en Marienbad. Una interpretación psicológica del film ‘El año pasado en Marienbad”. En FILMHISTORIA, Vol. 31, N°1.
Sollers, Philippe (1978). “Sept propositions sur Alain Robbe-Grillet”. En Obliques, N°16-17.
Sontag, Susan (1969). Contra la interpretación. Trad. de Horacio Vázquez Rial. Seix Barral.
Stoltzfus, Ben (1985). Alain Robbe-Grillet: The body of the text. Associated University Presses.
Suleiman, Susan (1990). Subversive intent: Gender, Politics, and the Avant-Garde. Harvard University Pres.
